Showing posts with label genetic engineering. Show all posts
Showing posts with label genetic engineering. Show all posts

Thursday, August 25, 2016

GENETIC ENGINEERING



 DNA manipulation


DNA REVOLUTION is the title of an interesting update on the topic by Michael Specter in the December 2016 issue of National Geographic, pages 30-55.  The prospects of using CRISPER, for genetically modifying organisms such as mosquitoes, was discussed along with the need for understanding the benefits and dangers of such genetic manipulation.  The article following, Science vs. Mosquitoes, by Cynthia Gorney, on pages 56-59 of the same issue helps demonstrate the positive value such genetic manipulation could have.

GMO’s, or genetically modified organisms, are often assumed to be dangerous when they occur in the food chain.  Although they could be made so, they also can be harmless as food.  A high level of safety as food can be achieved if goals and procedures are appropriate.  The speed of developing beneficial traits can be much greater than with conventional breeding programs.  Waiting for natural selection to produce useful natural variants through evolution is not an assured way of getting new useful variants in our lifetime.


Some possible benefits of genetic engineering of food organisms. 


Greater yield and/or better adaptation to agricultural processes and environmental conditions may be expedited by finding useful genes for transfer from other organisms unlikely to interbreed naturally.  More success may be found by transferring genes from different strains of the same species.   Examples of expected benefits include drought resistance, stronger stems to resist breakage due to wind or heavy rain, resistance to disease organisms and insects, higher ratio of edible parts versus other structural parts, higher nutrient content, and improved flavor or other attributes.

The uniformity achieved by planting hybrid seed for crops might possibly be accomplished by genetic engineering.  The reduced variation in size and shape of plants makes it much easier to effectively harvest them by machines.


Some possible hazards of genetic engineering of organisms.


Every engineered organism released into the environment has the potential to disrupt the ecological balance achieved by natural populations in much the same way an invasive species or introduced organism may disrupt the balance.  Just as with introduced species, sometimes we like the result.  But the potential for disaster is what we fear.  There is usually no reset button we can push to start over without the disastrous introduced organism.

The relative simplicity and/or ease with which genetic manipulation can be done makes it possible for laboratory errors or contamination to result in release of dangerous GMO’s into the environment.

One of the greatest fears that made pioneers of genetic engineering pause and help put safety procedures in place with strict containment and decontamination procedures was the inadvertent release of normally benign organisms containing toxins of disease organisms.

A fear that terrorists might inadvertently destroy the world, with release of lethal organisms that do not recognize boundaries separating friends from foes, could be disastrous for civilization as we know it.  The suicidal mentality projected to that scale seems unlikely, but we seem to get a foretaste of it in past terrorism events.

Molecular biologists initiated standards for recombinant DNA research beginning over 40 years ago.  Containment and other standards were a feature incorporated in federal research grants as a consequence.  But the tremendous progress in the field has simplified the process so that it is feasible for individuals to undertake projects outside of grant supported research programs and regulated facilities.

Ecological considerations.


The success of engineered species could make their use so prevalent that related native ones might not survive.  The diversified gene pool of native species is conducive to some surviving both new and old strains of fungi, bacteria, and viruses.  If a new insect pest or a disease develops for the engineered species it could spread very rapidly through all the closely adjacent populations of it.

Diversity of species is high in most undisturbed natural communities.  As the area of a natural community is reduced, diversity is usually reduced as well.  The interdependence of species is shown by the loss of one species causing the demise of species dependent on that species.  Even predators can help preserve their prey species by keeping their numbers at reasonable levels.  Reasonable levels include population levels that do not destroy their own food supply and make infectious disease transmission more of a certainty.

The web of life encompasses more than many appreciate, but it should not be ignored.


Ethical considerations.


Genetic engineering is here.  We should insist that benefits clearly outweigh the penalties and risks of each project and that no victims are trampled in our blind enthusiasm.  Are there some things that should not be attempted?

Consider the pesky mosquitoes.  Yes, they have killed millions by their role in transmitting malaria, yellow fever, and other diseases.  Does their value in the food chain, for bats and swallows, fish and many other aquatic organisms as well as possible role in plant pollination, mean they should not be eliminated?  They probably do not play an essential role in survival of most, or perhaps all, of those organisms; that makes the targeting of particular mosquito species easier to advocate, especially using CRISPER if it leaves no toxic residues.

Presumably, CRISPER includes improved techniques for controlling mosquitoes by targeting only the species that are vectors of importance in disease transmission.  A few decades ago targeted DNA adjustments of male mosquitoes, producing only males in their offspring which would then only produce males also, was demonstrated as a way of eliminating a species in a limited study.  Since only females feed on blood needed to produce viable eggs, blood feeding and disease transmission ends.  The result would seem to be one of the least disruptive control mechanisms possible.

Because engineered species may affect other nations directly or indirectly, international agreement should be obtained if they have not already done so.  The United Nations would be a proper entity to provide oversight by establishment of an appropriate commission or process.  Genetic engineering of one's own cells for cancer treatment would be an example of an exempt activity if viral vectors are not part of the process.

I would suggest praying for divine guidance be a personal matter in our philosophical pluralistic society, although it is much needed.  Fortunately, all major elements of our society share most values in their moral codes; peace, personal freedom for all, save our environment, and help those in need seem to be givens.


Joseph Engemann      Kalamazoo, Michigan        August 25, 2016

Wednesday, August 12, 2015

GOOGLE and SCIENCE

A THANK YOU FOR GOOGLE

A TV business news item said Google was going to do some genetic engineering of mosquitoes to control pest populations.  Why the thank you?

The technology for doing such work is over thirty years old.  But business in general will not fund such biological control projects because once they are in place they tend to be self-sustaining and not a source of continuing profits.

Such projects should be funded by government research and other grants because they can benefit all in much greater proportion than their cost.  But in our anti-taxing environment there is no one to effectively compete with other research that is more likely to benefit big business.

So Google deserves a big thank you from all of us for putting money into an important project with small monetary reward.  It gets money put to good use a little quicker than waiting for the owners to fund good projects with their estates.

Notice that pharmaceutical companies go to great lengths to produce new drugs to keep their profits high from non-generic versions that may be no better than generic drugs.

An example of the biological control of pests is the introduction of milky spore bacteria into soil where Japanese Beetles are established.  One treatment is likely to give long lasting control keeping populations very low.  The chemical companies probably prefer you use a pesticide that need repeated applications.

The genetic modification of mosquitoes is almost assured to only control the species modified.  Chemical controls are seldom so well targeted.  Environmental modification can help.  In Michigan, malaria is no longer naturally occurring due largely to screened windows, drained swamps, and perhaps some other measures.  But draining swamps has made it difficult for some populations of fish, birds, amphibians, and perhaps others to resist extinction.

The techniques likely to be used for mosquito control do not include the introduction of genes hazardous to other organisms or ourselves.  Most genetically modified organisms are not a hazard when incorporated in the food chain.  Some that use genes for toxins would need to be further studied.

The likely approach for mosquito control will introduce genes into the male that will cause the female they fertilize to only produce male offspring with the same engineered feature.  Male mosquitoes don't feed on blood, only the female does.  A variety of parasites are transmitted by mosquitoes, malaria is the major worldwide threat.

Thanks again, Google

Joseph G. Engemann    Kalamazoo, Michigan   August 12, 2015