NEW EVIDENCE FROM A PLANT STUDY
The continuing error of accepting divergence times from genetic evidence without adjusting for generation time is shown by a new study (Wilf, P,, M. A. Carvalho, M. A. Gandolfo, and N. Ruben-Cuneo. 2017. Eocene lantern fruits from Gondwanan Patagonia and the early origin of Solanaceae. Science, 355:71-75). I think they got it right.
Their research shows a minimum divergence time for fossil lantern fruits of the Pysalinae of 52.2 million years ago. That differs greatly from three different molecular divergence estimates of ~30, ~11, and ~9 million years ago.
Therefore, it seems evident that the error described in my blog of May 31, 2013 applies to some work on evolutionary, or ancestral, trees of plants as well.
If you read the blog post [ evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2013/05/science-screw-up-no-1.html ] you may recognize GIGO used to describe the algorhythms used in molecular phylogeny that do not include a generation time correction. Early generations of computer programmers used it to mean GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT when errors were input into programs. The principle still applies when conceptual errors are not accounted for, it isn't the computer that is making the mistake,
The generation time error is especially gross when applied to distant relationships.
Joseph G. Engemann Emeritus Professor of Biology, Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo February 15, 2017
Evolution insights presents evidence of new views of evolution as well as discussion of old and sometimes erroneous views. Other topics of interest to me, and I hope others, are interspersed; primarily views of God, creativity, and science. Current events, major and minor, are also distractions presented.
Showing posts with label molecular biology errors. Show all posts
Showing posts with label molecular biology errors. Show all posts
Wednesday, February 15, 2017
Tuesday, November 25, 2014
EVOLUTION: MOLECULAR CLOCKS
MOLECULAR
CLOCKS AND EVOLUTION
Here are
a few copied and pasted annotated references, from a file of references on the
computer I currently use, that may help show the validity of my 6th
post – Science Screw-up No. 1 – posted May 31, 2013. I shudder when I think how many others were
lost in various ways from the overwhelming amount of literature on the topics
that interested me enough to make index cards, entries on earlier computers, and
stacks of journals and clippings still unpacked from moves. Some were cited in the post noted above, but lacked the annotations and/or quotes from the articles.
Because
structure and functions of organisms are the direct targets of natural selection they
can be a better clue to branching pattern of the tree of life until the
generation time of organisms is properly incorporated in the process of tree
construction. Many of my posts rely on this concept for interpreting relationships as well as the views of natural history oriented biologists.
MOLECULAR
CLOCK VARIABLES
Ayala,
Francisco J. 1997. Vagaries of the molecular clock. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 94:7776-7783.
Found as much as a ten-fold difference between divergence times
estimated by two different Drosophila
genes (GPDH and SOD, or, glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase and super oxide
dismutase). Generation times were
identical in this study so did not affect the rate variation determined.
Bleiweiss,
Robert. 1998. Slow rate of molecular evolution in high-elevation
hummingbirds. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 95:612-616. “A slower rate of single-copy DNA change at
higher elevations suggests that the dynamics of molecular evolution cannot be
separated from the environmental context.” The effect remained “significant
even after taking into account a significant negative association between body
mass and molecular rate.”
Britten,
Roy J. 1986. Rates of DNA sequence evolution differ
between taxonomic groups. Science, 231:1393-1398. “Examination of available measurements shows
that rates of DNA change of different phylogenetic groups differ by a factor of
5. The slowest rates are observed for
some higher primates and..”
Buckley,
Thomas R., Chris Simon, and Geoffrey K. Chambers. 2001.
Exploring among-site rate variation models in a maximum likelihood
framework using empirical data: effects of model assumptions on estimates of
topology, branch lengths, and bootstrap support. Syst.
Biol., 50(1):67-86. variation in
variability across data sets changes estimates, under different model
assumptions, of nodal support and branch length
Campbell,
J. H. 1987. The New Gene and Its Evolution. Pp. 283-309 in Campbell, K. S. W., and M. F.
Day (Eds.). Rates of Evolution. Allen
and Unwin, London . 314 pp.
Rates of evolution pp 303- “To the extent that biological mechanisms
participate in evolutionary change they allow its rate to be programmed
internally as an attribute of the species.”
Clegg, Michael T., Michael P. Cummings, and
Mary L. Durbin. 1997. The evolution of plant nuclear genes. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 94:7791-7798.
“Analyses of synonymous nucleotide substitution rates for Adh genes in
monocots reject a linear relationship with clock time.” New genes that encode the enzymes
ribulose-1,5-biphosphate carboxylase and alcohol dehydrogenases occurred at ten
times the rate of new genes for alcohol dehydrogenases.
Field,
Katharine G., Gary J. Olsen, David
J. Lane , Stephen J. Giovannoni, Michael T.
Ghiselin, Elizabeth C. Raff, Norman R. Pace, and Rudolf A. Raff. 1988.
Molecular phylogeny of the animal kingdom. Science,
239:748-753. “Coelomates are thus
monophyletic, and they radiated rapidly into four groups: chordates,
echinoderms, arthropods, and eucoelomate protostomes.” “The use of cellular RNA for these studies
guarantees that sequences will represent commonly transcribed RNA genes, not
minor or inactive genes. The method
provides sequences in the most conservative portions of the 18S rRNA molecule, which are the most
useful for broad phylogenetic comparisons.” see following sentence page 748
also [“For distantly related organisms, it is not possible to establish
homology between nucleotides in the rapidly evolving portions of the molecule;
thus, even if the entire 18s rRNA sequence is known, only some parts of it can
be used for phylogenetic inference.”].
Study was based on 18S
ribosomal RNA sequences. Pogonophoran used was a thermal-vent species, annelids
were a polychaete and an earthworm, chordates were a tunicate, amphioxus, a
frog, and a human.
Fitch,
Walter M., Robin M. Bush, Catherine A. Bender, and Nancy J. Cox. 1997.
Long term trends in the evolution of H(3) HA1 human influenza type A. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 94:7712-7718.
Variation of replacement substitution rate of codons as much 7.2 times
greater in a hypervariable one. Rate
lowest in trunk codons, intermediate in twigs, and greatest in tip
branches. [thought added 2/6/03 – might be an
expression of selection against deleterious substitutions eliminated more
effectively due to time as one goes to older twigs and trunk. (jge) I had just
been thinking of that while trying to improve on method of calibrating
molecular clocks with generation time corrections for both calibration species
(if not from lines studied) and generation time difference of branch species (A
correction of up to 199.999% of uncorrected bifurcation value is needed if
generation time of shortest lived species was used; whereas estimate could need
reduction of up to 99.999% if based on longest lived species); therefore two
separate generations time corrections must be considered if calibration species
is a third species; no correction for generation time is needed if all three
have same generation time.]
Gillooly,
James F., Andrew P. Allen, Geoffrey B. West, and James H. Brown. 2005.
The rate of DNA evolution: effects of body size and temperature on the
molecular clock. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 102:140-145. support a single molecular clock, “but that
it “ticks” at a constant substitution rate per unit of mass-specific metabolic
energy rather than per unit of time.”
Keightley,
Peter D., and Adam Eyre-Walker.
2000. Deleterious mutations and
the evolution of sex. Science, 290:331-333. [13 Oct 2000 ]
Deleterious mutations were eliminated more rapidly in short generation
time species. The study did not support
(MD) “mutational deterministic” hypothesis for obligate sexuality.
Kimura,
Motoo, and Tomoko Ohta. 1971. On the
rate of molecular evolution. J. Molec. Evolution, 1:1-17. citing
various sources for a rate of about one centipauling for histones to four
paulings for Fibrinopeptide A. (1
pauling = “rate of substitution of 10 [to minus 9] per amino acid site per
year.)
Kuman,
Sudhir, and S. Blair Hedges. 1998. A molecular timescale for vertebrate
evolution. Nature, 392:917-920. [30 Apr 1998 ] In estimates of divergence times using
different genes, a standard error of about 10% was found using ten genes, but
the standard error was only 5% if 50 genes were used and 3% with use of 100
genes. Their study used 658 genes
distributed among 207 species of vertebrates (mostly mammals). [note added 11/25, 2014 - this shows the ability of statistical
analysis to give a more precise wrong answer, if a uniform rate premise is
wrong – a point of my May 31, 2013 post; see Maley and Marshall, 1998 below
also]
Laird,
Charles D., Betty L. McConaughy, and Brian J. McCarthy. 1969.
Rate of fixation of nucleotide substitutions in evolution. Nature,
224:149-154. a ten-fold higher rate of nucleotide sequence variation for
rodents compared to artiodactyls is found when time estimates are in years “This difference diminishes if generations,
rather than years, represent the appropriate interval of evolutionary
divergence.”
Maley,
Laura E., and Charles R. Marshall.
1998. The coming of age of
molecular systematics. Science, 279:505-506. “Growing evidence suggests that phylogenies
of animal phyla constructed by the analysis of 18S rRNA sequences may not be as
accurate as originally thought.” . . .
“In extreme cases the inferred relationships between groups may change
when different representative species are used.” . . “as the amount of data
analyzed increases, so does the apparent statistical support for an incorrect
phylogenetic tree.”
Mishmar,
Dan, Eduardo Ruiz-Pesini, Pawel Golik, Vincent Macaulay, Andrew G. Clark, Seyed
Hosseini, Martin Brandon, Kirk Easley, Estella Chen, Michael D. Brown, Rem I.
Sukernik, Antonel Olckers, and Douglas C. Wallace. 2003.
Natural selection shaped regional mtDNA variation in humans. Proc.
Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 100(1):171-176.
p. 171-“multiple amino acid changes found in ATP6, cytochrome b, and
cytochrome oxidase I appeared to be functionally significant. From these analyses we conclude that
selection may have played a role in shaping human regional mtDNA variation and
that one of the selective influences was climate.” P. 176 –“If selection has played an important
role in the human mtDNA lineages, then the rate of mtDNA molecular clock may
not have been constant throughout human history. If this is the case, then conjectures about
the timing of human migrations may need to be reassessed.”
Miyamoto,
Michael M., Jerry L. Slightom, and Morris Goodman. 1987.
Phylogenetic relations of humans and African apes from DNA sequences in
the ψη-globin region. Science, 238:369-373. “. . the slowdown in the rate of sequence
evolution evident in higher primates is especially pronounced in humans.”
Mooers,
Arne Ø., and Edward C. Holmes.
2000. The evolution of base
composition and phylogenetic inference. Trends in Ecology and Evolution (TREE),
15(9):365-369. “. . , in the early 1990s, phylogeneticists discovered that the
variation in GC content among organisms could wreak havoc on attempts to
reconstruct evolutionary history. This
was because the tree-building techniques then in use often grouped together
unrelated species with similar GC content.”
Nichols,
Richard. 2001. Gene trees and species trees are not the
same. Trends in Ecology and Evolution (TREE), 16(7):358-364. different genes may evolve at different
points in time in the same lineage giving different times of separation if only
one is considered to calculate divergence time
Shaw, Kerry
L. 2002.
Conflict between nuclear and mitochondrial DNA phylogenies of a recent
species radiation: What mtDNA reveals and conceals about modes of speciation in
Hawaiian crickets. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 99:16122-16127. “The discrepancy between mtDNA and nDNA
phylogenies reveals that speciation histories based on mtDNA alone can be
extensively misleading.”
Simmonds,
P., and D. B. Smith. 1999. Structural constraints on RNA virus
evolution. Journal of Virology, 73(7):5787-5794. Evidence of rate of mutations variation with
nucleotide location in relation to secondary structure of GB virus C. In this case, molecular clock assumptions are
incorrect.
Joseph Engemann Kalamazoo, Michigan November 25, 2014
Wednesday, September 17, 2014
SCIENCE
Science: Data Selection
DATA SELECTION
Scientists view data selection as forbidden. That is certainly appropriate in a well-designed study if everything goes smoothly. But it seems appropriate to exclude data that results from defective instrumentation, obvious errors in recording data, and inclusion of data not meant to be part of a class being compared. Any departures from selecting data after it has been collected should be included in notes of research reports. Even the best of intentions of researchers can sometimes result in compromised data that should never have reached publication after good peer review. Some examples I have encountered follow.
Salamander growth
An excellent field study done by a former colleague showed a continuously rising straight-line growth curve. My familiarity with growth curves from investigating the principle of growth pertinent to my study of protozoans during my master's research project and crustacean growth in my doctoral research made me dubious about the salamander growth reported for the Central American salamanders. Dr. Vial informed me that his doctoral committee had approved excluding some data thought to be defective in the study.
I was discussing his study with him after a seminar he presented about it. Successive years data from salamanders that had not grown were excluded for fear that they were not from the same salamanders but were ones that had lost toes that made them misidentified as ones from his toe-clipped sample. I don't remember for certain if they were also excluded for possibly not showing any growth due to tail loss and incomplete regeneration of a new tail.
It is likely that his salamanders growth slowed with age due to one or more of the many factors that can slow growth. The rapid growth of young individuals slows and in many species stops before natural death occurs.
1. Energy put into growth diminishes as more energy is put in to reproduction. 2. Increased size may not be accompanied by an accompanying supply of materials for growth. 3. Accumulation of waste within cells may slow growth. 4. Conversion of l-isomers of amino acids to d-isomers may interfere with metabolism. 5. Telomeres of the chromosomes may be reduced beyond numbers needed for growth. And, 6. Genetic control causing growth cessation may have evolved through natural selection to keep the species age class composition supplied with young and vibrant individuals. Regions where such populations occurred would likely replace adjacent populations not doing so.
Remote sensing
Another colleague made the assumption that remote sensing of lake colors by satellite could measure lake quality. The assumption was correct in a general way but I knew of one specific case where it did not work as planned. Asylum Lake was one I frequently sampled with my aquatic ecology (limnology) classes. Years of food wastes had polluted it severely although recovery was proceeding after it stopped.
During the years of his study I had noticed the surface often had many floating bits of duckweed, one of the smallest aquatic green plants. Their chlorophyll is of a type associated with green algae that are found in lakes not severely polluted. The algae suspended in water beneath the surface were primarily blue-green algae which are indicative of lakes over-enriched with phosphorus. So the lake by that assessment was eutrophic and not oligotrophic as the remote sensing indicated.
Molecular biology errors
From my reference file is the following entry.
Lewin, Roger. 1988. DNA clock conflict continues. Science, 241:1756-1759. describes article of Charles Sibley and Jon Ahlquist using DNA hybridization criticized by Vincent Sarich and others – wrong side (Sarich) seemed to win charging selection of data but Sarich Tmode used by him is selection of a worse sort.
Sibley's work was a study of bird relationships. He had eliminated some data that were obviously contaminated as he knew by his experience with the technique and had properly noted in his work. His approach seems to have been abandoned, unfortunately since it avoids data selection flaws found in much recent work.
This blog's post of 5/31/2013 entitled Science screw-up No. 1 describes a major episode still not resolved resulting in an invalid interpretation of animal phyla relationships.
Missing data
Finding data that we did not know was missing is an unforeseeable event that, when found, enabled me to see some important aspects of origin of animal groups. Many posts starting in late June 2013 related to annelid theory of chordate origin and the pogonophorans may help clarify the significance of Webb's publications about the finding of the formerly unknown segmented posterior extremity of pogonophorans.
Estimating the time of glacial retreat in Michigan based on strata of bog vegetation carbon-dated ages has developed with a possible error. Fossil carbon of low activity was probably incorporated in bog vegetation from carbon derived from ancient carbonate deposits dissolved in water entering lakes where the plants grew. This missing aspect of the data would give an older age to the age estimated proportional to the percentage incorporated.
The errors and other criticized findings you may find in my blog may be indicative of the value of an old saying - that we can or should learn from our mistakes; also that if you are afraid to make a mistake you are not likely to find anything. I thank them all, if they hadn't tried, I wouldn't have much to say.
Joseph G. Engemann September 17, 2014
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)