REVISED TREE OF LIFE
The revised tree of life described in the previous post lacked any illustration to aide understanding. The transfer of files to a new computer, operating system and associated software (Windows Vista to Windows 10) has delayed production of something suitable. I was eventually able to find Paint embedded in 10. But my attempt to modify the diagram below with color to clarify the protostome and deuterostome groupings left an illustration dangling somewhere in a jpg file that I have not been able to migrate to this blog.
The protostomes began with platyhelminthes, the flatworms ancestral to other protostomes, and eventually deuterostomes via annelids. The anthropocentric view showing primates upper right as the ultimate chordates is only for illustration of our lineage. Every living group could have an illustration showing their group at the peak. Some hint of this is shown with wasps and flies being groups of insects at the upper left. And at the far left the cephalopods are perhaps the ultimate mollusks.
The boldface names in the above diagram represent groups in the direct ancestral line to primates. All animals with a eucoelomate body cavity are included in the annelids and those above them in he diagram. Phylum names are in all capital letters. Polychaetes are probably the ancestral annelids for other annelids (oligochaetes and their descendants the leeches), mollusks, and arthropods, as well as the pogonophorans. Echinoderms and lophophorates were probably each derived from ancestors intermediate between polychaetes and hemichordates; echinoderms perhaps being farther along the line to chordates in their origin.
The various other groups are not all fairly treated in showing how advanced they are in an evolutionary sense. Their position is generally more an estimate of the antiquity of their origin.
OLDER VERSIONS OF THE TREE OF LIFE
A. Prior to the erroneous Lophotrochozoa and Ecdysozoa proposals the "Tree of Life" would have looked much like the version presented above with the following evident.
1. a separate origin of the deutrostomes from much earlier connecting the Hemichordates via unknown intermediates to the platyhelminthes.
2. a consequence is the assumption of a separate origin of coelom and blood vascular system of deuterostomes and advanced protostomes.
3. inexplicable cellular, histological, and moleular similarities in advanced protostomes and deuterostomes.
B. The Lophotrochoza error may some value as an assessment of lophophorate invertebrates but is not much use as showing relationships to vertebrates and some other phyla.
C. The Ecdysozoa error is made worthless by trying to make nematodes an important part of the evolutionary history of other some other phyla. Nematodes, as partially indicated in the diagram above, are probably part of an aschelminth group derived from turbellarian flatworms miniaturized by selection for adaptation for life in the interstices of marine, then freshwater and terrestrial sediments. The extreme specialization of nematodes did not provide a good base for selection of new groups. The superficial resemblance of their outer covering with the exoskeleton of arthropods is misleading. Surprisingly or fortunately, they did not make reptiles part of the group for shedding their skin. The post of May 31, 2013 should make it evident why the molecular data they used as a basis for Ecdysozoa is worthless.
D. Other versions of the "tree of life" based on symmetry and other features such as segmentation are not in vogue today, although the data used for them may have application in limited portions of "the tree of life". The antiquity of brachiopods and bryozoans as well as considerable differences in the lophophores would seem to argue for separate origins, perhaps from somewhere along the polychaete to pogonophora line.
E. The ancient annelid theory (over 100 years old) can be tweaked by insertion of the pogonophora to explain several things as shown elsewhere in the blog and indicated by the above diagram.
1. How the pogonophora turned an annelid arrangement of systems in to the chordate pattern.
2. How the anterior nervous system could fuse into a brain without an esophagus penetrating it.
3. How the drastic embryological changes of spiral to radial cleavage were simply made.
4. How molecular homologies of chordates and advanced protostomes came about.
Joseph G. Engemann Emeritus Professor of Biological Science, Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, Michigan May 16, 2016
Disclaimer: All errors, mistakes, and omissions are my own and not the responsibility of Michigan State University, The University of Tasmania, nor Western Michigan University, nor the U. S. Fulbright Agency; although their assistance was valuable enabling me to make them. jge
Evolution insights presents evidence of new views of evolution as well as discussion of old and sometimes erroneous views. Other topics of interest to me, and I hope others, are interspersed; primarily views of God, creativity, and science. Current events, major and minor, are also distractions presented.
Showing posts with label annelid theory of chordate origin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label annelid theory of chordate origin. Show all posts
Monday, May 16, 2016
Monday, September 7, 2015
INVERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY
INVERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY IS FUNDAMENTAL TO UNDERSTANDING EVOLUTION
Understanding the story of animal evolution is very dependent on knowledge of invertebrates. Vertebrates are recent (ok, the last half billion years), but very important, contributors to understanding the evolutionary history of animals. Darwin mostly used vertebrate examples in explaining his understanding of natural selection, Darwin's finches being the primary example. His studies of domestication of vertebrates also helped. But he also contributed to our understanding of invertebrates such as coral reefs, barnacles, and earthworms.
What make invertebrate zoology so useful?
There are many species representing different parts of the evolutionary tree of life. They provide steps along the transition from simple to complex structure and diversity. As research subjects many of them have the advantages of
1 short life cycles
2 small size
Together it greatly simplifies getting adequate data in studying many phenomena. It keeps costs down for care of subjects and allows varied approaches to be used in a short time. The ethical problems of care of subject animals seems less, but should not be ignored.
3 abundant numbers are usually available in nature for field observation.
4 many extinct species have left fossils; their small size often providing intact fossils.
Examples of contributions of invertebrate zoologists
E. O. Wilson observed social behavior of ants and other insects and conceived the sub-discipline of ecology and/or animal behavior termed SOCIOBIOLOGY.
Paul Ehrlich developed his understanding of population ecology, in part, from his studies of lepidopterous insect populations, and applied it to his concerns for overpopulation by humans in an influential book, The Population Bomb.
Alfred Kinsey transferred from years of studying wasps to studies of human sexuality.
Libbie Hyman [ http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2015/03/abandoned-theories-and-libbie-hyman.html ] studied hydras and planarians and stayed mostly an invertebrate zoologist of great breadth.
Robert Pennak was my hero for his excellent book on aquatic invertebrates of the United States. It has an excellent introductory discussion of the the transition of marine groups to fresh water.
Robert Barnes wrote an excellent invertebrate zoology text, especially in coverage of his specialty, polychaete worms. If he had put insects and parasites in his first edition I would probably never have undertaken the revision of Hegner's invertebrate zoology text. Meglitsch produced an impressive invertebrate zoology text that never received the recognition of Barnes' text which had largely been adopted by invertebrate zoologists.
A two volume text by Beklemishev (translated from the Russian) was a remarkable comparative anatomy of invertebrates. Its value as a reference is somewhat marred by his belief that animals should be grouped according to the extent of their segmentation.
As invertebrate zoology becomes a minor part of biological education in today's universities, it is unlikely that it will attract authors to update the subject to the extent it was done in the past. The digital age has made it unlikely that many will read the specialty journals and be exposed serendipitously to insights inspired by seemingly unconnected topics. On the other hand, I have seen some weird results produced by search engines, so maybe there is hope.
Why did I become an invertebrate zoologist?
The reasons are somewhat lost in time. But my first application for graduate school was to a botany department. I had actually had more interest in invertebrates from using Hegner's Invertebrate Zoology text. The variety was amazing, there were so many species, I thought maybe I could become the world's expert in some obscure group (I don't think I was very competitive). I had been a little put off by the extreme need for grades motivating pre-Med student friends. Plants were soon eliminated along with vertebrates due to sneezing and wheezing triggered by pollen and animal dander, factors seldom a problem with aquatic animals.
I had some vague notion that I might make some momentous discovery studying an obscure invertebrate. I knew that was unrealistic. Even so, dabbling in varied topics, I seem to be the only zoologist who realizes the abandoned annelid theory should be reinstated with modification to include the role of the pogonophorans as a central part of the theory. The evidence that abyssal animals can live extremely long lives [ http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2015/05/abyssal-ocean-environment-and-extreme.html ] and provide reason molecular phylogenies need reworking is something I hope to make others understand.
Joseph G. Engemann Kalamazoo, Michigan September 7, 2015
Understanding the story of animal evolution is very dependent on knowledge of invertebrates. Vertebrates are recent (ok, the last half billion years), but very important, contributors to understanding the evolutionary history of animals. Darwin mostly used vertebrate examples in explaining his understanding of natural selection, Darwin's finches being the primary example. His studies of domestication of vertebrates also helped. But he also contributed to our understanding of invertebrates such as coral reefs, barnacles, and earthworms.
What make invertebrate zoology so useful?
There are many species representing different parts of the evolutionary tree of life. They provide steps along the transition from simple to complex structure and diversity. As research subjects many of them have the advantages of
1 short life cycles
2 small size
Together it greatly simplifies getting adequate data in studying many phenomena. It keeps costs down for care of subjects and allows varied approaches to be used in a short time. The ethical problems of care of subject animals seems less, but should not be ignored.
3 abundant numbers are usually available in nature for field observation.
4 many extinct species have left fossils; their small size often providing intact fossils.
Examples of contributions of invertebrate zoologists
E. O. Wilson observed social behavior of ants and other insects and conceived the sub-discipline of ecology and/or animal behavior termed SOCIOBIOLOGY.
Paul Ehrlich developed his understanding of population ecology, in part, from his studies of lepidopterous insect populations, and applied it to his concerns for overpopulation by humans in an influential book, The Population Bomb.
Alfred Kinsey transferred from years of studying wasps to studies of human sexuality.
Libbie Hyman [ http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2015/03/abandoned-theories-and-libbie-hyman.html ] studied hydras and planarians and stayed mostly an invertebrate zoologist of great breadth.
Robert Pennak was my hero for his excellent book on aquatic invertebrates of the United States. It has an excellent introductory discussion of the the transition of marine groups to fresh water.
Robert Barnes wrote an excellent invertebrate zoology text, especially in coverage of his specialty, polychaete worms. If he had put insects and parasites in his first edition I would probably never have undertaken the revision of Hegner's invertebrate zoology text. Meglitsch produced an impressive invertebrate zoology text that never received the recognition of Barnes' text which had largely been adopted by invertebrate zoologists.
A two volume text by Beklemishev (translated from the Russian) was a remarkable comparative anatomy of invertebrates. Its value as a reference is somewhat marred by his belief that animals should be grouped according to the extent of their segmentation.
As invertebrate zoology becomes a minor part of biological education in today's universities, it is unlikely that it will attract authors to update the subject to the extent it was done in the past. The digital age has made it unlikely that many will read the specialty journals and be exposed serendipitously to insights inspired by seemingly unconnected topics. On the other hand, I have seen some weird results produced by search engines, so maybe there is hope.
Why did I become an invertebrate zoologist?
The reasons are somewhat lost in time. But my first application for graduate school was to a botany department. I had actually had more interest in invertebrates from using Hegner's Invertebrate Zoology text. The variety was amazing, there were so many species, I thought maybe I could become the world's expert in some obscure group (I don't think I was very competitive). I had been a little put off by the extreme need for grades motivating pre-Med student friends. Plants were soon eliminated along with vertebrates due to sneezing and wheezing triggered by pollen and animal dander, factors seldom a problem with aquatic animals.
I had some vague notion that I might make some momentous discovery studying an obscure invertebrate. I knew that was unrealistic. Even so, dabbling in varied topics, I seem to be the only zoologist who realizes the abandoned annelid theory should be reinstated with modification to include the role of the pogonophorans as a central part of the theory. The evidence that abyssal animals can live extremely long lives [ http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2015/05/abyssal-ocean-environment-and-extreme.html ] and provide reason molecular phylogenies need reworking is something I hope to make others understand.
Joseph G. Engemann Kalamazoo, Michigan September 7, 2015
Monday, May 4, 2015
EVOLUTION: ANNELIDS TO CHORDATES, THE MIDDLE STEP
THE MIDDLE STEP
The pogonophora to hemichordate transition is the most difficult step to see because pogonophorans are most easily seen as specialized polychaete annelids; and hemichordates are generally accepted as being in the chordate line. So the big step from the first (the protostome part of the lineage) to the last (the deuterostome part of the lineage) faces the greatest difficulty in seeing for those not familiar with what I have tried to show in earlier posts about this topic.
An obstacle is the residue left from past objections when the annelid theory was thought to be discredited by embryological and molecular evidence. Why those objections are irrelevant has been treated in earlier posts.
SOME GRAPHIC EVIDENCE OF THE MIDDLE STEP
A, B, and C illustrate the progression of stages from early larva to adult anterior of the hemichordate, Saccoglossus.
D, E, and G illustrate the progression of comparable stages of the pogonophoran, Siboglinum.
F illustrates the segmented posterior portion of an adult Siboglinum, and G- its anterior.
H illustrates the anterior of a giant pogonophoran from a thermal vent community. (A, B, and C, after Hyman and others; D, E, F, and G, adapted fromEngemann and Hegner after Webb; H, from a specimen in the U. S. National Museum.) [Fig. 12-5 in my unpublished 2010 manuscript, Evolution Insights.]
F, above, illustrates the posterior segmentation not reported until done so by Webb [Webb, M. 1964. The posterior extremity of Siboglinum fiordicum (Pogonophora). Sarsia, 15:33-36]. Possibly the segmented end of some species lost this region, or an intermediate species did before becoming hemichordates.
G and H show some of the variability of the anteriors of pogonophorans that resemble the anterior of C, a hemichordate.
A and D are not as precisely alike as one might like. But this was near the evolutionary step where the early embryology was changing drastically from protostome to deuterostome embryology.
REFERENCES to many of the research articles influential in helping me see the protostome-deuterostome connection, especially the molecular evidence showing the error of current studies were posted in
http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2014/11/evolution-molecular-clocks.html
which you can get to by using the Blog Archive at the right and clicking on the 2014 November arrows. Or send the address above to a friend you think might find it interesting. Most of the references are annotated with my comments to myself or quotations from the article.
Joseph G. Engemann Emeritus Professor of Biology, Western Michigan University May 4, 2015
The pogonophora to hemichordate transition is the most difficult step to see because pogonophorans are most easily seen as specialized polychaete annelids; and hemichordates are generally accepted as being in the chordate line. So the big step from the first (the protostome part of the lineage) to the last (the deuterostome part of the lineage) faces the greatest difficulty in seeing for those not familiar with what I have tried to show in earlier posts about this topic.
An obstacle is the residue left from past objections when the annelid theory was thought to be discredited by embryological and molecular evidence. Why those objections are irrelevant has been treated in earlier posts.
SOME GRAPHIC EVIDENCE OF THE MIDDLE STEP
A, B, and C illustrate the progression of stages from early larva to adult anterior of the hemichordate, Saccoglossus.
D, E, and G illustrate the progression of comparable stages of the pogonophoran, Siboglinum.
F illustrates the segmented posterior portion of an adult Siboglinum, and G- its anterior.
H illustrates the anterior of a giant pogonophoran from a thermal vent community. (A, B, and C, after Hyman and others; D, E, F, and G, adapted fromEngemann and Hegner after Webb; H, from a specimen in the U. S. National Museum.) [Fig. 12-5 in my unpublished 2010 manuscript, Evolution Insights.]
F, above, illustrates the posterior segmentation not reported until done so by Webb [Webb, M. 1964. The posterior extremity of Siboglinum fiordicum (Pogonophora). Sarsia, 15:33-36]. Possibly the segmented end of some species lost this region, or an intermediate species did before becoming hemichordates.
G and H show some of the variability of the anteriors of pogonophorans that resemble the anterior of C, a hemichordate.
A and D are not as precisely alike as one might like. But this was near the evolutionary step where the early embryology was changing drastically from protostome to deuterostome embryology.
REFERENCES to many of the research articles influential in helping me see the protostome-deuterostome connection, especially the molecular evidence showing the error of current studies were posted in
http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2014/11/evolution-molecular-clocks.html
which you can get to by using the Blog Archive at the right and clicking on the 2014 November arrows. Or send the address above to a friend you think might find it interesting. Most of the references are annotated with my comments to myself or quotations from the article.
Joseph G. Engemann Emeritus Professor of Biology, Western Michigan University May 4, 2015
Monday, November 11, 2013
CREATIVITY: HONESTY HELPS
Honesty was a section in The Two Way Street, my 1970's unpublished manuscript on creativity, Chapter 4, A Creative Frame of Mind. The section reads as follows-
Honesty is essential to the maintenance of creativity. Honesty with others will reduce self-deception. Honesty does not mean that everything known must be used or told. Honesty must be coupled with the proper evaluation to be complete. Accurate evaluation will make it easy to determine the best use.
When honesty has been practiced so long and with such diligence that it is automatic, judgments and estimates will be realistic. The resultant accuracy can contribute to the accuracy of derivative hypotheses.
The defense of honesty should include the careful labeling of humor. The unrealistic aspect of humor should not blend with the real and confuse, rather it should delight by its contrast. Thus the choice of humor should be determined by the audience, not the teller. Perhaps a sophisticated listener can discriminate on a very fine scale and appreciate what would be uniform and bland to the less sophisticated. So also, honesty is partially determined by the listener, be it self or someone else. Is it honesty to state something true when we know it is or will be misunderstood? If we are willing to state something it is pointless to say anything unless we are willing to say it clearly.
A cartoon to amplify the third sentence of the above quotation showed a woman and a man in their backyard, each talking over adjacent sides of the fence to another woman and another man. The quotation under the cartoon could be attributed to either one talking, it reads "I wish what went in Pat's ear went out the other ear instead of the mouth."
Honesty makes life easier when you don't have to clutter up your mind with lies or misinformation. It makes it easier to keep from believing what started out as a lie. It makes it easier to believe others; but evaluating information as it comes in may make it easier to reject untrue information.
A basic faith in the honesty of scientists made me look beyond the conflict of the view Gans and Northcutt present, as noted in blogs 16 and 17, June 23 and 24, 2013, and make the major discovery of how the two main groups of animals are linked. That view reestablishing the annelid theory of chordate origin has yet to be understood by my peers.
Joseph G. Engemann November 11, 2013
Saturday, August 3, 2013
EVOLUTION OF MOLLUSKS
The big three
Annelids, arthropods, and
mollusks are three major invertebrate phyla, with coeloms and blood vascular
systems, that have successfully expanded from probable marine origins into
freshwater and terrestrial environments.
Their close relationship was suspected for over a century because of the
annelid cross. The annelid cross was a
peculiar relationship of four cells found in at least some of the early embryos
of all three phyla.
Annelids and arthropods are
easily seen to be closely related because of their obvious metamerism,
cuticles, and general relationships of some systems. But all but some recently discovered mollusks
lack obvious metamerism. So which came
first, mollusks or metamerism?
Annelid origin of mollusks
The discovery (Lemche an
Wingstrand, 1959) of a living member of the Monoplacophora, Neopilina, in 1952 helped answer the
question. It had obvious remnants of
metamerism in paired nerves, blood vessels, and muscles. The single pair of ventricles straddled the
posterior portion of the gut and helps illustrate the way the unusual
perirectal ventricle of bivalves evolved to enclose that portion of the gut.
McAlester (1964) provided
further evidence of the monoplacophoran-bivalve connection with the
intermediate fossil, Babinka. Figure 9-41 (above), on page 479 of
Invertebrate Zoology, 3rd ed.,
by Engemann and Hegner (1981) illustrates the transition of muscle scars those of modern bivalves such as the clam, Anodonta.
The fossil studied by Sutton
et al. (2001) helped fill the gap between polychaete annelids and
mollusks. They reported it had a polychaete-like
body with 7 small calcareous dorsal valves spaced along the dorsal surface. They named it Acaenoplax
hayae gen. nov. and sp. nov. in Phylum Mollusca, and the fossil
they “interpret as a plated aplacophoran.”
Structure was determined by computerized reconstruction of serially ground sections. The only internal structure was a
tube in some sections thought to be a gut.
A space may indicate the position of an undeveloped valve. The posterior 7th valve has a
ventral portion as well as a dorsal portion.
About 18 ridges circling top and sides bear setae and give a
polychaete-like appearance in their photos.
The molluscan shell as a
cause of loss of metamerism
The success of the cone-shaped
shell and the muscular foot may well have made the survival value of repeated
structures less valuable for survival. Hence
the loss of appendages and segmentation was promoted by the protective
shell.
It is easy to make a transitional
series of gastropod shells from limpets to elongated and spiral shells arising
from the monoplacophoran type. From
gastropods with siphons to cephalopods with their jet propulsion is less clear
but quite likely.
References
Engemann, Joseph G., and Robert W. Hegner. 1981.
Invertebrate Zoology, 3rd ed.
Macmillan Publishing Co., New
York . 746 pp.
Lemche, H., and K. G. Wingstrand. 1959.
The anatomy of Neopilina galatheae,
1957. Galathea Report, 3:9-72. +56 Pl.
McAlester,
A. Lee. 1964. Transitional Ordovician bivalve with both
monoplacophoran and lucinacean affinities.
Science, 146:1293-1294. Babinka
has muscle scars intermediate between the monoplacophoran, Neopilina, and modern bivalves.
Sutton,
Mark D., Derek E. G. Briggs, David J. Siveter and Derek J. Siveter. 2001.
An exceptionally preserved vermiform mollusc from the Silurian of
England. Nature, 410:461-463.
Joseph G. Engemann August 3, 2013
Sunday, June 30, 2013
EVOLUTION PROTOSTOME-DEUTEROSTOME LINK
EVOLUTION – ANNELID THEORY
BIBLIOGRAPHY a supplement to earlier post today.
I will not feel bad if you don’t read this, even if you are a
biologist. If you have a specific
interest in annelid theory of chordate origin, the references may be helpful.
The references below are some
that I found useful in understanding the evolution of the animal phyla,
especially as pertains to the annelid theory.
They tend to focus on molecular aspects if I thought they shed light on the
problem. The bibliography is a partial
one and could have been greatly expanded if for example, I included all those
that did not make a link to both protostomes and deuterostomes [Akam, Michael,
1998, Biol. Bull., 195:373-374 deals
with shifts in Hox gene expression in
segments during evolution of arthropods] or my database was defective [a 1978
invertebrate collagens article in Science,
202:591-598 has an obvious defect in the author’s name(s)]. Since disappointment with the defects [noted in my 5/31/13 post] of some phylogenetic studies over a decade ago, I have not been very attentive to subsequent reports.
Arendt, D., and K. NĂ¼bler-Jung. 1994.
Inversion of dorsoventral axis? Nature, 371:26.
Arendt, Detlev, Ulrich Technau, and Joachim Wittbrodt. 2001.
Evolution of the bilaterian larval foregut. Nature,
409:81-85.
De Robertis, E. M., and Yoshiki Sasai. 1996.
A common plan for dorsoventral patterning in Bilateria. Nature,
380:37-40.
Eakin, Richard M. 1979.
Evolutionary significance of photoreceptors: in retrospect. Am.
Zool., 19:647-653. Fig. 1 shows
great similarity of photoreceptors of annelids and cephalochordates although he
puts them near the tips of separate lines
Field, Katharine G., Gary J. Olsen, David J. Lane , Stephen J. Giovannoni,
Michael T. Ghiselin, Elizabeth C. Raff, Norman R. Pace, and Rudolf A.
Raff. 1988. Molecular phylogeny of the animal kingdom. Science,
239:748-753. “Coelomates are thus
monophyletic, and they radiated rapidly into four groups: chordates,
echinoderms, arthropods, and eucoelomate protostomes.”
Gardiner, Stephen L., and Meredith L. Jones. 1985.
Ultrastructure of spermiogenesis in the vestimentiferans tube worm Riftia pachyptila (Pogonophora:
Obturata). Trans. Am. Microsc. Soc., 104(1):19-44.
Gould, James L.
1985. How bees remember flower
shapes. Science, 227:1492-1494.
“presumptive vertebrate-invertebrate dichotomy is false” bees use search and memory process similar to
vertebrates.
Lull, Richard Swann.
1945. Organic Evolution. Macmillan , New
York . 744pp.
[Revised edition, 1929, earlier 1917] a paleontologist at Yale. Fig. 123, page 429 after Wilder of annelid
theory of vertebrate origin
Meurling, Patrick.
1967. The vascularization of the
pituitary in elasmobranchs. Sarsia, 28:1-104.
Miyamoto, Michael M., Jerry L. Slightom, and Morris
Goodman. 1987. Phylogenetic relations of humans and African
apes from DNA sequences in the ψη-globin region. Science,
238:369-373. “. . the slowdown in the
rate of sequence evolution evident in higher primates is especially pronounced
in humans.”
Moore,
Richard C., and Michael D. Purugganan.
2003. The early stages of
duplicate gene evolution. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA,
100:15682-15687. “Gene duplications are
one of the primary driving forces in the evolution of genomes and genetic
systems.”
Pellettieri,
Jason, and Geraldine Seydoux. 2002. Anterior-posterior polarity in C. elegans and Drosophia-PARallels and differences. Science,
298:1946-1950. “par” genes important in polarization for C. elegans embryo; homologs were discovered in mammals, this study
looks at fruit fly
Peterson,
Kevin J., Steven Q. Irvine, R. Andrew Cameron, and Eric H. Davidson. 2000.
Quantitative assessment of Hox
complex expression in the indirect development of the polychaete annelid Chaetopterus sp. Proc.
Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 97:4487-4492.
they found a similar Hox
complex utilization in cells for adult body plan in the polychaete to that
process described in the sea urchin
Ritzmann,
Roy E., Martha L. Tobias, and Charles R. Fourtner. 1980.
Flight activity initiated via giant interneurons of the cockroach:
evidence for bifunctional trigger interneurons.
Science, 210:443-445. “command or trigger interneurons have been
identified . . . . including annelids,
arthropod, mollusks, and turtle (1).”
Romer,
Alfred Sherwood. 1962. The
Vertebrate Body, 3rd edition.
Saunders, Philadelphia . 627 pp.
Illustration of annelid theory of chordate origin is on page 25 (same as
Lull one but different caption) see pages 298-299 for transition in position of
structures leading to pituitary – p. 298
Ruppert, Edward E., and Elizabeth J. Balser. 1986.
Nephridia in the larvae of hemichordates and echinoderms. Biol.
Bull., 171:188-196.
Sarnat, Harvey B.
1984. Muscle histochemistry of
the planarian Dugesia tigrina
(Turbellaria: Tricladida): implications in the evolution of muscle. Trans.
Am. Microsc. Soc., 103(3):284-294.
Schwenk, Kurt, and GĂ¼nter P. Wagner. 2001.
Function and the evolution of phenotypic stability: connecting pattern to process. Amer.
Zool., 41:552-563.
Smith, Peter R., Edward E. Ruppert, and Stephen L.
Gardiner. 1987. A deuterostome-like nephridium in the
mitraria larva of Owenia fusiformis
(Polychaeta, Annelida). Biol. Bull., 172:315-323.
Southward, Alan J., and Eve C. Southward. 1982.
The role of dissolved organic matter in the nutrition of deep-sea
benthos. Amer. Zool., 22:647-658.
Stein, Elizabeth A., and Edwin L. Cooper. 1983.
Inflammatory responses in annelids.
Am. Zool., 23:145-156.
inflammation of vertebrates and annelids shows related factors – histamine,
agglutinins, lysins, etc. also have
amoeboid phagocytic cells
Stoichet, Sarah A., Talat H. Malik, Joel H. Rothman, and
Ramesh A. Shivdasani. 2000. Action of the Caenorhabditis elegans GATA factor END-1 in Xenopus suggests that similar mechanisms initiate endoderm
development in ecdysozoa and vertebrates.
Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., USA ,
97:4076-4081.
Terwilliger, R. C., and N. B. Terwilliger. 1987.
Are pogonophoran and annelid extracellular hemoglobin structures similar
to one another? Am. Zoologist, 27(4):32A, abstract #152. Yes for Vestimentifera which also have a
smaller Hb similar to one found in Perivata
Tiplady, Brian, and Morris Goodman. 1977.
Primitive haemoglobin. J. Mol. Evol., 9:343-347. “The variations in nucleotide substitution
rates were interpreted in terms of Darwinian selection, the emergence of a new
function being followed by a rapid rate of evolution, which then slows down once
the molecule has been optimized.”
Tomarov, Stanislav I., Patrick Callaerts, Lidia Kos, Rina
Zinovieva, Georg Halder, Walter Gehring, and Joram Piatigorsky. 1997.
Squid Pax-6 and eye
development. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 94:2421-2426. (March 1997) “Pax-6
in vertebrates and its homolog eyeless
in Drosophila are known to be
essential for eye development.”
Wagner, Gunte P., Chris Amemiya, and Frank Ruddle. 2003.
Hox cluster duplications and the opportunity for evolutionary
novelties. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 100:14603-14606. “Hox genes play a key role in animal body
plan development. These genes tend to
occur in tightly linked clusters in the genome.
Vertebrates and invertebrates differ in their Hox cluster number, with
vertebrates having multiple clusters and invertebrates usually having only
one.”
Joseph G. Engemann
June 30, 2013
EVOLUTION - SINGLE ORIGIN OF COELOMATES
MONOPHYLETIC ORIGIN OF COELOMATES
Segmentation as a starting
point
Annelids are the animals most
like the ancestral form of all coelomates.
Their segmentation enabled the speedy evolution of diversity. That diversity includes forms that show
little evidence of the remnants of segmentation. Metamerism, of chordates and some other
phyla, is the repetition of organs or structure along the length of a body that
no longer has segmentation.
The serial repetition of
structures enables regional modification of appendages and other structures
from a relatively complex base with minimal genetic changes. This is illustrated most clearly by arthropod
appendages. It is evident in our own
pectoral and pelvic appendages, although not so obviously having an early stage
of origin in segmentation. Our early
embryo has some of the more convincing evidence in myotomes; adults have vertebrae
with paired nerves, blood vessels, and muscles that may also be convincing.
Reduction of segmentation in
the chordate line was a result of its loss by pogonophorans in the portion of
the body retained in hemichordate evolution.
Most mollusks lost evidence of metamerism as a result of the shell
removing benefits of obvious metamerism. A vermiform fossil shows evidence of
the annelid origin of mollusks (Sutton et al. 2001); and a fossil, Neopilina, shows a more molluscan
intermediate stage (Lemche, 1957). Arthropods have striking evidence of
metamerism externally in most groups, both with skeletal segmentation and
appendages
Just as segmentation was
modified beyond easy recognition, the coelom was also greatly modified as
higher animals diversified. Coeloms, found in both the protostome line and the deuterostome line, but not
in animals earlier than annelids, provide evidence of the annelid origin of coelomates.
Nephridia
Water and salt regulation is
an important function of our kidney. The
annelid nephridium, with pairs in most of their segments, was modified by evolution
into the nephrons of our kidneys; an intermediate connection is shown by
Ruppert and Balser, 1986. The oviduct
also seems to be a nephron modification.
The water-vascular system of echinoderms may be derived from nephridia; the
water-vascular system stays open to the exterior, indicating the echinoderms
have probably lost the benefits of osmoregulation and thus never were able to
survive in fresh water.
Blood
The central position of
annelids in the ancestry of coelomates may be illustrated by blood
pigments. Polychaete worms have as many
as four different oxygen transporting pigments in the blood. Higher forms typically have one of those pigments, in
our case, hemoglobin.
Other Molecular Evidence
Once I thought the
Pogonophora were the deuterostome connection to protostomes (1983), I found a
lot of supporting molecular evidence.
One of the first was the finding of Lipman and Pearson (1985) that
crayfish Trypsin I is high-scoring for similarity to bovine trypsinogen.
The interpretation of
molecular evidence is complicated by the fact that vertebrates tend to have
some important genetic features in family clusters of genes whereas other
animals typically have only one from a family.
Also, the same molecules may act in somewhat similar but different ways
in different groups. Hobmayer et al.
(2000) found the WNT signaling pathway that had been found in nematodes,
insects, and vertebrates (all with bilateral symmetry) also acted in axis
formation of a radially symmetric cnidarian.
The protostome-deuterostome transition
via pogonophorans may be returned to at some later date. I expect to end the topic with my next post
of a few additional references, some annotated, from my reference file that deal
in some way with the topic, most about molecular evidence.
In summary, a wide variety of
evidence points to the basic truth of
the annelid theory of chordate origin.
References
Hobmayer, Bert, Fabian
Rentzsch, and 6 others. 2000. WNT signaling molecules act in axis formation
in the diploblastic metazoan Hydra. Nature,
407:186-189.
Lemche, H. 1957.
A new living deep-sea mollusk of the Cambro-Devonian class
Monoplacophora. Nature, 179:413-416.
Lipman, David J., and William
R. Pearson. 1985. Rapid and sensitive protein similarity
searches. Science, 227:1435-1441.
Ruppert, Edward E., and
Elizabeth J. Balser. 1986. Nephridia in the larvae of hemichordates and
echinoderms. Biol. Bull., 171:188-196.
Sutton, Mark D., Derek E. G.
Briggs, David J. Siveter and Derek J. Siveter.
2001. An exceptionally preserved vermiform
mollusc from the Silurian of England. Nature, 410:461-463.
Joseph G. Engemann June 30, 2013
Friday, June 28, 2013
EVOLUTION of systems inversion
EVOLUTION – ORIGIN OF DEUTEROSTOME SYSTEM INVERSION
Several major steps were
involved in the inversion of systems as polychaete annelids gave rise to the
chordate line of deuterostomes.
First
a branch of tube-dwelling, bottom-dwelling polychaetes evolved with some reduction
of clear segmentation; development of a plume of tentacles for feeding and/or
respiration probably was occurring as well.
A variety of marine species having a similar intermediate condition
still exist.
The
second major step involved the complete adaptation to life in abyssal sediments
as pogonophoran worms. This included (1)
a loss of dorso-ventral distinctions common to species ancestral to groups with
radial symmetry, (2) reduction of development of the gut, (3) increased
reliance on passive absorption of nutrients, and (3) retention of the
circulatory system to provide oxygen to the portion of the worm embedded in low
oxygen sediments.
The
embryological changes noted in the previous post were occurring simultaneously
with these changes. They now are the
pogonophorans, well-adapted to survive the extinction events of pre-Cambrian
times. The major feature identifying
them as annelid descendants was the extreme lower segmented and setae bearing
portion that was not noticed in specimens of early collections made by dredges that
did not retrieve whole worms; the deeply embedded part presumably was left
in the ocean bottom.
The
third major step in the protostome-deuterostome journey was the sequence of
changes as descendants moved to shallower seas during the period following the
intense asteroid bombardment (see May 11 post). Those
moving from their tubes to reach particulate food more abundant on shallower
sea sediments found it less jarring to the nervous system to emerge with the
previous ventral nervous system of the annelids positioned so it was nearer the
upper surface. In such a position, a remnant
of the gut, perhaps more substantial because of the greater abundance of food,
put endodermal and ectodermal tissue closer together to induce the mouth
formation associated with such an event.
A
further consequence of this new position of the mouth enabled fusion of ganglia
and connectives to form a brain without encircling the esophagus. These and other changes above were
facilitated by natural selection of those with genetic modifications better
serving the processes.
The culmination
of this process needed very little fine tuning to make a hemichordate, probably
the closest annelid derivative to the chordate line of deuterostomes. The larval stages of pogonophorans and
hemichordates are very similar.
Correspondence of the anterior of a hemichordate and the upper portion of
a certain pogonophorans is quite similar.
The lowest segmented portion of the pogonophoran degenerated to leave
three body regions some think are characteristic of chordates. Previous discussions indicated the speed of
loss of features not contributing to survival by the greater energy left over
for reproduction is a common feature in evolutionary events.
Clearly,
pogonophorans are excellent candidates
for the missing link clarifying the inversion of systems suggested by the annelid
theory of chordate origin.
BRING
BACK THE ANNELID THEORY.
Joseph
G. Engemann June 28, 2013
Sunday, June 23, 2013
EVOLUTION
ORIGIN OF DEUTEROSTOMES
Abandoned views
Once natural selection was
accepted as the way evolution of species produced the variety of life on earth,
it became a goal to determine the ancestral line of intermediate forms leading
to the major groups of animals. A series
of successive creations suggested by the drastic changes in the geologic fossil
record had earlier been suggested but abandoned. Likewise the concept of inheritance of
acquired characteristics was seldom considered after an understanding of
genetic inheritance developed.
Features of some value
Radial symmetry versus
bilateral symmetry was given some emphasis for a while. The grades of body complexity were, and still
are, given considerable significance.
Grades went from cellular level, to tissue level, to organ system
level. The most primitive of those with
organ systems had only a mouth opening, whereas the more advanced had both
mouth and anus. Blood vascular systems
represented a greater advance. Skeletal
systems, segmentation, and metamerism complicated the picture as different
branches of the ancestral tree diverged.
Invertebrates and vertebrates
were treated as two vastly different groups in some ways and may have been a
major factor in the annelid theory of chordate origin never getting full
acceptance. The recognition of
embryological differences of protostomes and deuterostomes made the presumption
of the deuterostome line separating from the protostome line at about the time
of the early flatworms a generally accepted view; the speed and ancestry
involved in the shift will be shown to differ from the recent views as well as
indicating the error of recently accepted proposals.
Time for return of the
annelid theory
The annelid theory of origin
was a result of the comparison of annelid worms and vertebrates when one was
inverted. When one is inverted and then
compared, the arrangement of nervous system and blood vessels and directions of
flow are similar. But the embryological
differences seemed insurmountable.
Biochemistry and genetics, as well as greater understanding of
embryology and biology made it evident that embryonic and larval features were
not a sure guide to determining ancestral paths. But, as Stephen J. Gould noted in his book (2002. The
Structure of Evolutionary Theory. The
Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. 1433 pp.), the annelid theory was not revived when the developmental grounds for
its dismissal were eliminated. The developmental
grounds do not need to be completely discounted; they can still be helpful if used with some
flexibility.
The inversion the annelid
theory encompasses still troubles the investigators below who imply other
explanations are needed for the inversion.
Arendt, D., and K. NĂ¼bler-Jung. 1994.
Inversion of dorsoventral axis? Nature, 371:26.
De Robertis, E. M. , and Yoshiki Sasai. 1996.
A common plan for dorsoventral patterning in Bilateria. Nature,
380:37-40.
Their efforts are
commendable, but unnecessary if the annelid theory is reinstated. Numerous other reasons to reinstate the
annelid theory of chordate origin exist.
Others have not yet shared in
my 1983 awakening to the validity of the annelid theory. By that time it was evident that the
Pogonophora were near relatives of polychaete annelids. But a conflicting paper revived the notion
that they were deuterostomes based on embryology. The article, quote, and notes from my
reference file are as follows:
Gans,
Carl, and R. Glenn Northcutt. 1983. Neural crest and the origin of vertebrates: a
new head. Science, 220:268-274. (15
April 1983) Includes Pogonophora in the
deuterostomes. “Both the neural crest and the epidermal placodes for
special sense organs and other neural structures. These structures may be homologous to
portions of the epidermal nerve plexus of protochordates. The transition to vertebrates apparently was
associated with a shift from a passive to an active mode of predation, so that
many of the features occurring only in vertebrates became concentrated in the
head.” This is the article that
triggered my (1983 eureka event) awareness of the pogonophorans as the
protostome-deuterostome link after initial disgust of their inclusion in the
deuterostomes.
Other factors lend support to the need for reinstatement of the annelid theory with the addition of the Pogonophora as a formerly missing link. A hint of the overwhelming evidence will be provided in blogs on embryology, inversion, anatomical, and other evidence.
Joseph G. Engemann June 23, 2013
Sunday, May 19, 2013
CREATIVITY and COGNITIVE DISSONANCE
Creativity and Cognitive Dissonance
COGNITIVE DISSONANCE, the protostome-deuterostome missing link found
The insoluble clash of mutually exclusive ideas may trigger creative solutions. This post was not edited from a previously written project as I intended to do for posts. So it is subject to being posted with lack of checking on details. But the term cognitive dissonance was one I learned of a long time ago in a workshop on teaching provided colleagues at Western Michigan University by Dr. Robert Travers and Dr. Greg Fisk. They were emphasizing creative approaches to teaching.
The previous post on creativity was one I was pleasantly surprised at getting posted since I had been having problems doing so. The morning paper inspired me. In it were two columns using the term cognitive dissonance; a term I have only found in the newspaper a few times before. One, on the first page of The Wall Street Journal Sunday inclusion within the business section written by Brett Arends (WSJ.com/Sunday), even used a cartoon illustration to show stock prices and interest rates make the bull and bear riders an instance of being on the same financial roller coaster, hence a case of cognitive dissonance. Stock prices and interest rates typically go in opposite directions.
My most enlightening case of cognitive dissonance was finding a worm that was put in two disparate parts of the animal kingdom. The conventional view put them in the annelid line of animals. A new view (Gans and Northcutt, 1983) put them in the opposite cluster of animals that humans are in based on their common embryology. I knew the existing data meant they had to be annelids, the new study noted they were in the vertebrate line based on embryology. I was somewhat irritated and distressed by what I knew, the new study had to be wrong.
As I thought how honest scientists have to be and how careful they are with their data I somehow thought the only way it could be true would be if the worms were an intermediate connecting link. The eureka moment came almost instantly, blending knowledge of the old annelid theory that had been rejected with the new embryological similarity to the vertebrate line. Differences were so great it had previously been thought to be necessary to go back to the flatworms to have a likely common ancestor for the annelid line and the vertebrate line.
The many other bits of evidence for the vertebrate line originating from the annelid level of animal development rapidly became apparent thanks to merger of disparate facts gained from others and from my research.
Gans, Carl, and R. Glenn Northcutt. 1983. Neural crest and the origin of vertebrates: a new head. Science, 220:268-274. (
Joseph G. Engemann May 19, 2013
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



