UPDATING MAINSTREAM IDEAS
About a half-century ago I was confused by the distinction between Darwinism and Neo-Darwinism. The "Neo" prefix had been added to designate the discoveries of Darwin enhanced by understanding of hereditary or genetic principles clarifying the principles of natural selection. Such proliferation of terms helps the specialists introducing them but brings confusion to the generalists.
Discovery of details of pogonophoran biology provides near certainty that the abandoned annelid theory of chordate ancestry was actually correct when modified as done in numerous posts on this evolutioninsights blog. The separation of the chordate line from protostomes via the polychaete - pogonophora - hemichordate - chephalochordaate sequence has sufficient evidence to justify abandoning the old idea that the deuterostome departure from protostomes was near the flatworm level.
Updating the annelid theory
First, the original abandonment of the annelid theory on embryological grounds was dismissed by the drastic differences between protostome and deuterostome development. This blog (June 24, 2013 etc.) is the only source showing a plausible reason for the change via the pogonophorans.
Second, the current popular distortion of animal phyla relationships is based on faulty research described in this site's blog of May 31, 2013. The post on Evolution: Molecular Clocks on November 25, 2014 contains numerous citations to research showing the great variations possible in studies based on molecular clocks.
Third, the input from ecological and structural studies shows the simplicity of inversion of systems to deuterostome chordates from protostome annelids via tube-dwelling polychaetes noted in Evolution of systems inversion posted June 28, 2013. Several other June 2013 posts should also be viewed.
Fourth, the post on EVOLUTION AND THE OLDEST ANIMAL, June 13, 2014, should be a great help understanding the unique evolutionary position of the pogonophorans and their position as a very important connecting link between the two major lines of higher animals.
Updating the Tree of Life
The June 30 2013 and subsequent posts to August 3, 2013 have information about the linking of mainstream invertebrate groups as well as arthropods and mollusks. There are many important subgroups of sponges, cnidarians, and flatworms in the mainstream. Interesting sideshoots include ctenophores, rotifers, nematodes. The protonemerteans are a hypothetical descendent of flatworms preceding the polychaete annelids; they represent the most uncertain guess for continuity in the protozoan to people ancestral tree. Arthropods and mollusks probably have separate origins from polychaete annelids.
Branches from uncertain places in the tree of life include lophophrates such as bryozoans and brachiopods, and echinoderms; they may be near the pogonophorans in origin. Chaetognathan origins are uncertain, as are the origins of a number of unsegmented worms.
Joseph Engemann, Emeritus Professor of Biology, Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, Michigan October 20, 2017
Evolution insights presents evidence of new views of evolution as well as discussion of old and sometimes erroneous views. Other topics of interest to me, and I hope others, are interspersed; primarily views of God, creativity, and science. Current events, major and minor, are also distractions presented.
Showing posts with label the tree of life. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the tree of life. Show all posts
Friday, October 20, 2017
Monday, February 2, 2015
EVOLUTION AND THE SECRET OF THE TREE OF LIFE
THE TREE OF LIFE
The tree of life, as currently accepted by main-stream science, has an unaccounted for error. It is no secret to you if you have read all my posts, but the molecular phylogeny of major phyla has major errors for lack of understanding long-branch attraction. Or as I have shown from numerous citations elsewhere, abundant evidence that direct measurement of DNA differences of species is almost certain to produce an erroneous tree-of-life for phyla if it is calculated from those differences.
LONG BRANCH ATTRACTION
Molecular phylogenies are sometimes plagued with the pogonophorans or some other group appearing in some central position in a phylogeny when the researcher is quite certain it should not be there. They may note that it doesn't seem to belong there, or, I suspect, sometimes they leave it out because they think it is a long-branch attraction appropriate to ignore. Maybe they just remember not to use the group for an out-group [a group inserted that is reasonably presumed to be outside the cluster being investigated]. The correct solution is to figure out why it happened - something they cannot do without introducing a major variable of molecular clocks all ignore. I have discussed elsewhere how the nematodes may also have a slower rate of change in their genome and thus produce an example of long branch attraction.
THE POGONOPHORA
The Pogonophora are specialized descendants of polychaete annelids of which the ancient ones are ancestral to all vertebrates via hemichordates and cephalochordates as indicated in Our Evolutionary Lineage (Post 79). [ http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2014/12/our-evolutionary-lineage.html ]
That post also lists approximate times of origins of groups in that lineage. From that we can see that the pogonophorans evolved about a billion years ago. Some are little changed to this day, if they stayed in the abyss, from perhaps 600 million years ago when the hemichordate line branched off from some of the pogonophorans moving into shallower waters. From hemichordates the cephalochordates branched off, perhaps 500 million years ago.
THE CAMBRIAN
About 500 million years ago the Cambrian began. Most major phyla had representatives in the Cambrian. Trilobites were arthropods whose fossils are only found in rocks through the Cambrian to the end of the Palaeozoic. Arthropods are obvious annelids descendants that have an origin from polychaetes, as do pogonophorans. Mollusks had a comparable origin from polychaetes.
The stability of conditions in the Cambrian enabled pogonophorans ancestors to migrate to shallower seas and survive following the end of major asteroid bombardment episodes. As they established themselves in shallow seas, the reduced pressure enabled physiological processes involving diffusion to speed up to a 1,000 times greater speed. A better food supply also contributed to the process. The recovery of gut development by the hemichordate descendants accompanied other developments as the worms moved out of their tubes and took on a more active life getting particulate food, mostly by filtration instead of the diffusion on which the pogonophorans had become dependent.
Parallel lines from the polychaete-pogonophora line gave rise to echinoderms and probably some of the lophophorate phyla that also made their appearance in the Cambrian.
CALCULATING THE LONG BRANCH ATTRACTION
We can ignore the fact that pogonophoran tube analysis (in earlier blogs) indicates the individuals can live from 10,000 to a million or more years. Just taking the pressure differential effect on physiology indicates evolutionary selection is likely to be 1,000 times more rapid in shallow seas than in abyssal ones.
The ancestor that remained and reproduced in the abyss over the past billion years would be expected to have one million nucleotide substitutions in their DNA while a descendant that had been near the surface has 500 million nucleotide substitutions in the past half-billion years. Another descendant branching off at the same time would also have 500 million nucleotide substitutions in the past half-billion years.
Others branching from the new lines, say one from each line 400 million years ago, each would have 400 million nucleotide substitutions in each of their lines as differences.
THE SURPRISE
Now, the four groups would all have more in common with the pogonophoran that now has half a million changes from the point of common ancestry with the other four groups that each has 500 million changes.
The branching of the new groups would be correctly interpreted from the differences as *800.0 million changes from their nearest relative and *1,000.0 million from each of their more distant pair of relatives, but only *500.5 million changes from the pogonophoran. The pogonophoran now looks closest to all by the long branch attraction, an artifact of different rates of evolution whether by physiological speed or long generation time, or by both as I think it is.
The closer the groups studied, in a phylogenetic study of relationships, the more likely it is that pogonophorans will not show up as a close relative within a group. Thus species, genus, and families in an order are unlikely to appear related to pogonophorans unless the study is of pogonophorans.
If you look at the estimated times of origins you can see that terrestrial vertebrate classes had their origins over three hundred million years ago. but most modern orders were likely beginning almost two hundred million years ago. Nearly the same thing could be said about the insects. Whereas echinoderms are a more ancient group with classes going back to the Cambrian; they even have several extinct classes.
Until the molecular phylogeneticists calculate a major tree of life taking the above into consideration they will continue to be wrong about their view of relationships of phyla. They have a lot to contribute if they stop making that error.
*The numbers used in the examples above are not precise and are only used for a simplified example of the principles involved and are calculated by summing the changes of both ancestral lines from their point of branching.
Joseph G. Engemann Kalamazoo, Michigan February 2, 2015
The tree of life, as currently accepted by main-stream science, has an unaccounted for error. It is no secret to you if you have read all my posts, but the molecular phylogeny of major phyla has major errors for lack of understanding long-branch attraction. Or as I have shown from numerous citations elsewhere, abundant evidence that direct measurement of DNA differences of species is almost certain to produce an erroneous tree-of-life for phyla if it is calculated from those differences.
LONG BRANCH ATTRACTION
Molecular phylogenies are sometimes plagued with the pogonophorans or some other group appearing in some central position in a phylogeny when the researcher is quite certain it should not be there. They may note that it doesn't seem to belong there, or, I suspect, sometimes they leave it out because they think it is a long-branch attraction appropriate to ignore. Maybe they just remember not to use the group for an out-group [a group inserted that is reasonably presumed to be outside the cluster being investigated]. The correct solution is to figure out why it happened - something they cannot do without introducing a major variable of molecular clocks all ignore. I have discussed elsewhere how the nematodes may also have a slower rate of change in their genome and thus produce an example of long branch attraction.
THE POGONOPHORA
The Pogonophora are specialized descendants of polychaete annelids of which the ancient ones are ancestral to all vertebrates via hemichordates and cephalochordates as indicated in Our Evolutionary Lineage (Post 79). [ http://evolutioninsights.blogspot.com/2014/12/our-evolutionary-lineage.html ]
That post also lists approximate times of origins of groups in that lineage. From that we can see that the pogonophorans evolved about a billion years ago. Some are little changed to this day, if they stayed in the abyss, from perhaps 600 million years ago when the hemichordate line branched off from some of the pogonophorans moving into shallower waters. From hemichordates the cephalochordates branched off, perhaps 500 million years ago.
THE CAMBRIAN
About 500 million years ago the Cambrian began. Most major phyla had representatives in the Cambrian. Trilobites were arthropods whose fossils are only found in rocks through the Cambrian to the end of the Palaeozoic. Arthropods are obvious annelids descendants that have an origin from polychaetes, as do pogonophorans. Mollusks had a comparable origin from polychaetes.
The stability of conditions in the Cambrian enabled pogonophorans ancestors to migrate to shallower seas and survive following the end of major asteroid bombardment episodes. As they established themselves in shallow seas, the reduced pressure enabled physiological processes involving diffusion to speed up to a 1,000 times greater speed. A better food supply also contributed to the process. The recovery of gut development by the hemichordate descendants accompanied other developments as the worms moved out of their tubes and took on a more active life getting particulate food, mostly by filtration instead of the diffusion on which the pogonophorans had become dependent.
Parallel lines from the polychaete-pogonophora line gave rise to echinoderms and probably some of the lophophorate phyla that also made their appearance in the Cambrian.
CALCULATING THE LONG BRANCH ATTRACTION
We can ignore the fact that pogonophoran tube analysis (in earlier blogs) indicates the individuals can live from 10,000 to a million or more years. Just taking the pressure differential effect on physiology indicates evolutionary selection is likely to be 1,000 times more rapid in shallow seas than in abyssal ones.
The ancestor that remained and reproduced in the abyss over the past billion years would be expected to have one million nucleotide substitutions in their DNA while a descendant that had been near the surface has 500 million nucleotide substitutions in the past half-billion years. Another descendant branching off at the same time would also have 500 million nucleotide substitutions in the past half-billion years.
Others branching from the new lines, say one from each line 400 million years ago, each would have 400 million nucleotide substitutions in each of their lines as differences.
THE SURPRISE
Now, the four groups would all have more in common with the pogonophoran that now has half a million changes from the point of common ancestry with the other four groups that each has 500 million changes.
The branching of the new groups would be correctly interpreted from the differences as *800.0 million changes from their nearest relative and *1,000.0 million from each of their more distant pair of relatives, but only *500.5 million changes from the pogonophoran. The pogonophoran now looks closest to all by the long branch attraction, an artifact of different rates of evolution whether by physiological speed or long generation time, or by both as I think it is.
The closer the groups studied, in a phylogenetic study of relationships, the more likely it is that pogonophorans will not show up as a close relative within a group. Thus species, genus, and families in an order are unlikely to appear related to pogonophorans unless the study is of pogonophorans.
If you look at the estimated times of origins you can see that terrestrial vertebrate classes had their origins over three hundred million years ago. but most modern orders were likely beginning almost two hundred million years ago. Nearly the same thing could be said about the insects. Whereas echinoderms are a more ancient group with classes going back to the Cambrian; they even have several extinct classes.
Until the molecular phylogeneticists calculate a major tree of life taking the above into consideration they will continue to be wrong about their view of relationships of phyla. They have a lot to contribute if they stop making that error.
*The numbers used in the examples above are not precise and are only used for a simplified example of the principles involved and are calculated by summing the changes of both ancestral lines from their point of branching.
Joseph G. Engemann Kalamazoo, Michigan February 2, 2015
Friday, December 12, 2014
OUR LINEAGE EXPLAINED
OUR EVOLUTIONARY LINEAGE
The preceding post of December 8, 2014 gives a condensed version of the evolutionary line listing 25 groups going backward from humans to an early animal group, the amoeboflagellates. The list ignores the many other lines of evolution leading to other existing groups of animals such as echinoderms, mollusks, arthropods, and classes of annelids other than the polychaetes. The polychaetes also are the earliest common ancestor of those groups as well as of all vertebrate groups.
The time scale of our ancestral tree follows the 25 groups of the first listing, but in reverse order with some additional steps beginning with the creation of elements and three other pre-biotic events not well covered in earlier posts. The elements were formed in a second or later generation of stars preceding our sun. They provided the material that eventually produced the more complex molecules from which living systems evolved on earth.
Those complex molecules formed from various processes as the earth cooled and the oceans formed. Carbon dioxide, ammonia, water, methane, and various minerals were the materials acted upon by heat, radiation, and lightening to produce amino acids and other compounds. Chance interactions of those compounds were probably enhanced by concentration in tidal pools. There the mixing by waves may have utilized not only products produced by adhesion to various rocks, but compounds imported by water currents from remote locations. One of those locations could well be the thermal vent areas proposed by Corliss as a place were life originated. But similar processes could have been enhanced at inter-tidal locations as lava flows entered the sea or at other volcanic locations.
Following the four pre-biotic steps are five steps leading to the choanoflagellates, the ancestral group from which all animals arose. Plants presumably are derived from earlier flagellated ancestors. The remaining steps as well as the preceding steps are only cameos along a continuum of populations of organisms usually much like their closest ancestors and descendants.
Ten steps from sponges to the first chordates took about a billion years to occur. The preceding evolution of living organisms took almost twice as long. From the earliest, almost worm-like, chordates to us took a little over a half-billion year. About eighty percent of that time was taken to produce the first primates. It is likely our ancestral line never included a monkey that could hang from its tail as some South American monkeys can.
I mentioned the later because a monkey, if it could philosophize, might pity us for having lost our tail. Likewise, the course of evolution includes many steps that might be considered regressive, but ones enabling later advances. One of the most prominent, but least known, of such type event is the reduction of systems suffered during the evolution of polychaete ancestors to our pogonophoran ancestors.
Joseph Engemann December 12, 2014
The preceding post of December 8, 2014 gives a condensed version of the evolutionary line listing 25 groups going backward from humans to an early animal group, the amoeboflagellates. The list ignores the many other lines of evolution leading to other existing groups of animals such as echinoderms, mollusks, arthropods, and classes of annelids other than the polychaetes. The polychaetes also are the earliest common ancestor of those groups as well as of all vertebrate groups.
The time scale of our ancestral tree follows the 25 groups of the first listing, but in reverse order with some additional steps beginning with the creation of elements and three other pre-biotic events not well covered in earlier posts. The elements were formed in a second or later generation of stars preceding our sun. They provided the material that eventually produced the more complex molecules from which living systems evolved on earth.
Those complex molecules formed from various processes as the earth cooled and the oceans formed. Carbon dioxide, ammonia, water, methane, and various minerals were the materials acted upon by heat, radiation, and lightening to produce amino acids and other compounds. Chance interactions of those compounds were probably enhanced by concentration in tidal pools. There the mixing by waves may have utilized not only products produced by adhesion to various rocks, but compounds imported by water currents from remote locations. One of those locations could well be the thermal vent areas proposed by Corliss as a place were life originated. But similar processes could have been enhanced at inter-tidal locations as lava flows entered the sea or at other volcanic locations.
Following the four pre-biotic steps are five steps leading to the choanoflagellates, the ancestral group from which all animals arose. Plants presumably are derived from earlier flagellated ancestors. The remaining steps as well as the preceding steps are only cameos along a continuum of populations of organisms usually much like their closest ancestors and descendants.
Ten steps from sponges to the first chordates took about a billion years to occur. The preceding evolution of living organisms took almost twice as long. From the earliest, almost worm-like, chordates to us took a little over a half-billion year. About eighty percent of that time was taken to produce the first primates. It is likely our ancestral line never included a monkey that could hang from its tail as some South American monkeys can.
I mentioned the later because a monkey, if it could philosophize, might pity us for having lost our tail. Likewise, the course of evolution includes many steps that might be considered regressive, but ones enabling later advances. One of the most prominent, but least known, of such type event is the reduction of systems suffered during the evolution of polychaete ancestors to our pogonophoran ancestors.
Joseph Engemann December 12, 2014
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)